Skip to product information
1 of 1

Polly's Pies

NEW! Cheesecake

NEW! Cheesecake

Regular price $38.99 USD
Regular price Sale price $38.99 USD
Sale Sold out
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Enjoy a Polly's Cheesecake from wherever you are! 

Treat yourself to something delightfully delicious with our NEW! Cheescake! Made from scratch and with a velvety texture that melts in your mouth, this plain cheesecake may not seem exciting - but trust us, it's far from plain! With its surprisingly scrumptious taste, you can't go wrong!

  • 8.25" diameter.
  • 8–10 servings (depends on how you slice it!)
  • Shipped frozen with dry ice. Freeze up to 3 weeks.
  • Our cheesecakes are all natural with NO preservatives.
  • No baking required! Keep frozen until ready to enjoy. Allow 12 hours for thawing in the refrigerator.
  • Enjoy within 48 hours after thawing.

We'll include thawing instructions in the package! You can also view them here.

Return Policy

Returns & Exchanges- Polly's Marketplace Items

  • We ask that you please inspect all contents of your package to check for damaged goods.
  • To return or exchange items in your order, please contact us within 72 hours of delivery at
  • For a return, we ask that you please include all contents of the package you received including goods, packaging, invoice slip, etc.
  • Guest will pay for return shipping.
  • After 72 hours have passed, we will be unable to process any returns or exchanges.
  • Unfortunately, we cannot accept returns on sale items or gift cards.
  • If you experience shipping delays or any other issues with your order, we are here to help! Please email so we can assist.

Returns & Exchanges- Bake at Home Pies

  • We are not able to provide refunds or exchanges for Bake at Home pies. 
  • Should you find any incorrect or missing items in your order or any damaged goods, please let us know right away! Email within 24 hours of receiving your order
  • We are not able to refund orders if notified past 24 hours of delivery.


We ship out orders on Mondays, Tuesdays, and Wednesdays for both marketplace items and Bake at Home Pies, Cinnamon Rolls, and Quiches. We do not ship on Thursdays, Fridays, Saturdays, or Sundays.

Marketplace items are shipped using UPS Ground unless express shipping has been paid for by the guest. Bake at Home Pies, Cinnamon Rolls, and Quiches are shipped using UPS Next Day Shipping. Any non-perishable items, coffee, and jams are shipped separately from Bake at Home items and we cannot guarantee a delivery date. 

View full details