Collection: Jams & Butters

Two pies surrounded by sliced apples, whole apples, blueberries, and a Polly's Pies shipping box in front of a white marble and yellow background.

Nationwide Shipping is on Pause

We've paused pie and bakery shipping for the Summer. We'll relaunch in Fall! Make sure you sign up for our eclub so you can be notified when we relaunch!

Apple Butter

Sold out

Apple Butter

Regular price $8.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $8.99 USD
Unit price per

Sold out
Pumpkin Butter

Sold out

Pumpkin Butter

Regular price $8.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $8.99 USD
Unit price per

Sold out
Signature Bumbleberry Jam

Sold out

Signature Bumbleberry Jam

Regular price $9.49 USD

Regular price Sale price $9.49 USD
Unit price per

Sold out
Strawberry Jam

Sold out

Strawberry Jam

Regular price $8.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $8.99 USD
Unit price per

Sold out

Collection: Jams & Butters

Nationwide Shipping is on Pause

Filter and sort

Filter

Let's Keep in Touch!